
A Madrid court has delivered an unprecedented ruling, ordering American tech giant Meta Platforms, the owner of Facebook and Instagram, to pay a colossal sum to Spanish media publishers from the Association of Information Media of Spain (AMI). The decision, announced on November 20, mandates Meta to pay €479 million (plus €60 million in interest, totaling approximately $552 million USD) for unfair competition and violating key European Union data protection regulations (GDPR).
NEWSROOM IN notes a brief explanation of the core claim, how the court identified Meta’s tactics, and why Meta’s effectiveness was deemed unlawful:
Meta Faces Unfair Competition and GDPR Legal Challenges
A crucial aspect of the court proceedings centered on Meta’s attempt to bypass the primary requirement of European GDPR law: the necessity of obtaining explicit user consent for data processing.
Initially, Meta relied on users’ presumed consent. However, as the law became stricter, the company adopted a different approach:
False Premise (‘Contract’)
To justify behavioral advertising, Meta tried to alter the legal basis, claiming that processing personal data was ‘necessary for the performance of a contract’. According to Meta, the ability to see targeted advertising was an integral part of the basic service for which users registered.
Implicit Ultimatum
By employing this legal maneuver, Meta essentially presented users with an ultimatum: either accept the new terms, or lose access to the service.
Breach of the Principle of Good Faith
Regulators found this tactic to be unlawful. They ruled that displaying targeted advertising is not a fundamental and necessary component of a social media service contract. By using this framing, Meta distorted user choice and deprived users of a genuine opportunity to opt out of data usage while retaining account access.
Unfair Competition: ‘Illegal Doping’
The illicit data collection enabled Meta to gain a ‘significant competitive advantage,’ which formed the basis of the lawsuit brought by 87 Spanish media publishers. The court determined that Meta was not merely ‘effective,’ but unlawfully effective.
Violation of Fair Play: Unlike Spanish media outlets, which were compelled to strictly adhere to GDPR, Meta effectively played by its own rules. This can be likened to a race where everyone is expected to run in sneakers, but Meta arrived on a high-speed motorcycle. While the motorcycle is faster, its use violates the established rules of the game.
Receiving ‘Doping’: The hyper-accuracy of Meta’s advertising, which attracted enormous advertising budgets, was achieved not through superior algorithms, but through illegally obtained ‘fuel’ – personal data collected without proper consent.
Damages and Compensation: Had Meta acted in good faith, the precision of its advertising would have decreased, and competition would have been on a level playing field. The court recognized that the illicit data collection distorted the advertising market, causing financial harm. Therefore, the €479 million compensation will be paid to the 87 media companies as restitution for damages, not as a fine to the state treasury.
Thus, the Spanish court’s decision represents an important precedent against the abuse of a dominant position and the use of legal loopholes to circumvent European privacy legislation.